Specialists have expressed warning over tea ingesting claims for sort 2 diabetes.

Forward of the annual assembly of the European Affiliation for the Examine of Diabetes, a number of specialists claimed that ingesting tea may defend individuals from sort 2 diabetes.

The declare is that individuals who drink 4 or extra cups of tea a day – particularly inexperienced, oolong or black tea – are 17% much less more likely to develop sort 2 diabetes than those that do not drink tea. Ingesting fewer cups of tea per day didn’t present any profit.

“Our findings are fascinating as a result of they counsel that folks can do one thing so simple as ingesting 4 cups of tea a day to probably scale back their threat of growing sort 2 diabetes,” mentioned Wuhan (China) College of Science and Expertise. Xiaoying Li of Expertise mentioned. mentioned in an official EASD press launch.

“It’s attainable that sure elements in tea, akin to polyphenols, can decrease blood glucose ranges, however enough quantities of those bioactive compounds could also be required to be efficient,” Dr. Li added. Lee added.

Kevin McConway, PhD, MSc, MBA, emeritus professor of utilized statistics on the Open College, mentioned the phrases ‘counsel’ and ‘probably’ are necessary right here. .

“Ingesting tea will solely be helpful for decreasing the chance of diabetes if ingesting tea reduces the chance, that means the chance is decreased in case you drink tea and never in case you do not – and this research simply does not can inform if it does or not,” emphasised Dr. Conway.

Naveed Sattar, FMedSci FRCPath FRCPGlas FRSE, Professor of Metabolic Drugs on the College of Glasgow, was additionally cautiously important. “There isn’t a good experimental proof that the chemical substances in tea stop diabetes,” he noticed individually.

“Subsequently, I’m extra skeptical about tea being more healthy (low calorie) than many different drinks or tea drinkers.”

Dr. Sattar added that it could be that individuals who drink tea might also be avoiding extra dangerous sugary drinks and different well being behaviors that decrease their threat of sort 2 diabetes. can

Tea time?

Dr. Lee will current the outcomes of two analyzes on the EASD assembly on September 21: the primary a big observational cohort research and the second a newer systematic overview and meta-analysis.

For the joint research, Dr. Li and his coauthors took knowledge from greater than 5,100 adults who participated within the long-running and ongoing China Well being and Diet Survey (CHNS). Info on tea ingesting conduct was extracted from questionnaires that have been crammed out at two time factors – 1997 and 2009 – and decided whether or not individuals had sort 2 diabetes based on American Diabetes Affiliation standards. has occurred

Virtually half, 45.8%, have been discovered to be tea drinkers, and 10% of these sampled had sort 2 diabetes. No affiliation was discovered between tea ingesting and the event of sort 2 diabetes, nonetheless, with the hazard ratio between tea drinkers and non-tea drinkers sitting firmly at 1.02. Moreover, a sensitivity evaluation excluding individuals who developed sort 2 diabetes within the first 3 years of follow-up didn’t change the outcomes.

Issues have been barely totally different when Dr. Li and colleagues carried out their meta-analysis, which included an evaluation of knowledge from greater than 1 million individuals in 19 research carried out in eight nations that had been printed as of September 2021.

Right here, they discovered that there was a major (P <.003) linear relationship between tea consumption and kind 2 diabetes, with every further cup of tea ingesting a 0.986 discount within the threat of sort 2 diabetes.

The HRs for growing sort 2 diabetes amongst tea drinkers in contrast with nontea drinkers have been 1.00 for many who drank lower than one cup per day, 0.96 for many who drank one to 2 cups, and 4 or extra. have been 0.84 for cup drinkers;

“Though extra analysis is required to find out the precise dosage and mechanism behind these observations, our outcomes counsel that ingesting tea could also be useful in decreasing the chance of sort 2 diabetes, however solely in giant quantities (one cup a day I at the very least 4 cups). Dr. Lee mentioned.

Maybe, “we did not discover an affiliation between tea ingesting and kind 2 diabetes in our cohort research as a result of we did not take a look at excessive tea consumption,” he added.

Tempest in a Teachup

“That is giant, observational knowledge. It isn’t a randomized managed trial so there’s plenty of room for misinterpretation of the information,” mentioned Matt Sides, MSc, professor of medical trials and methodology on the MRC Medical Trials Unit, College School London. warned

“Everybody drinks fluids. If there’s an impact right here (and it is a huge one), it is not concerning the tea they drink, however about what they do not drink. Proper now, nobody can inform. It appears unlikely that a big randomized managed trial might be carried out to disambiguate.

“Being solely a convention summary, it is tough to evaluate the standard of this analysis,” mentioned Baptiste Leverant, PhD, a medical statistician who additionally works at College School London. They identified that not solely was the cohort research observational, so have been all different research included within the meta-analysis.

“Subsequently, no cause-and-effect conclusions may be drawn. The affiliation might merely be resulting from different elements, akin to those that drink extra tea having a more healthy life-style. The authors don’t seem to have managed for confounding.” tried to seek out, which is normally tough in meta-analysis,” mentioned Dr. Leverant.

Jonathan Prepare dinner of the Heart for Statistics in Drugs on the College of Oxford (England) mentioned, “There’s motive to be slightly skeptical at this level; we want fuller particulars to essentially assess this correctly.” “It is a truthful try to have a look at it, however regardless, [using] A reasonably normal strategy.”

Related research have decreased the chance related to ingesting espresso, famous Duane Mellor, PhD, a registered dietitian and senior educating fellow at Aston College in Birmingham.

“The important thing take-home message is that life-style is important to managing the chance of sort 2 diabetes,” mentioned Dr. Miller.

“This consists of selecting low-calorie drinks, together with primarily water, in addition to unsweetened tea and occasional, as a part of a wholesome life-style.”

This research was funded by the Younger Expertise Challenge of the Hubei Provincial Well being Fee, the Science and Expertise Analysis Key Challenge of the Schooling Division of Hubei Province, the Sano Diabetes Charity Basis, and the Xiangyang Science and Expertise Plan Challenge. Dr. Lee had no conflicts of curiosity to reveal. Dr. McConway is a trustee and on the advisory committee of the Science Media Heart. Dr. Sattar has consulted for a lot of diabetes and cardiovascular drug corporations and has been concerned in quite a few trials of life-style approaches for diabetes prevention and remission. Dr. Sides, Dr. Leverant, Dr. Prepare dinner, and Dr. Miller don’t have any conflicts of curiosity to report.

This story initially appeared on, a part of the Medscape Skilled Community.

About the author


Leave a Comment